/
Benchmarking : Foundational Identity Platform

Benchmarking : Foundational Identity Platform

Foundational identity platforms are core digital infrastructure designed to establish and manage the unique identification of individuals across multiple systems. Unlike functional ID systems that serve specific programs (e.g., insurance, education, or voting), foundational ID platforms like MOSIP, or IDPASS provide a universal identity backbone that can be reused across sectors. These platforms typically support biometric deduplication, demographic verification, and secure identity authentication, making them crucial for ensuring that each individual can be uniquely and reliably identified in systems like openIMIS. Their integration enables real-time validation during enrolment and claim processes, significantly reducing identity fraud, duplication, and eligibility errors in social protection and healthcare.

Key considerations when evaluating a foundational identity platform include:

  • Identity Assurance Level: The system’s capacity to enforce unique identification through biometric deduplication or strong credentialing.

  • Interoperability: Availability of APIs and compliance with standards like OAuth2, OpenID Connect, and FHIR for seamless integration with systems like openIMIS and openCRVS.

  • Authentication Services: Inclusion of an identity broker such as eSignet to manage secure logins and consent-based data sharing.

  • Scalability and Resilience: Support for national-scale deployments with millions of identities and high transaction volumes.

  • Privacy and Consent Frameworks: Adherence to data protection laws and user-controlled data sharing, especially when handling sensitive demographic or biometric data.

  • Modular Architecture: Ability to adapt or replace components such as credential issuance, verification, or data brokers depending on national needs.

 

MOSIP

Integration & Standards

  • MOSIP offers robust API-first architecture, with support for REST, OpenID Connect (OIDC), and OAuth 2.0, enabling seamless integration with platforms like openIMIS, openCRVS, and middleware like openHIM.

  • While not healthcare-specific, MOSIP’s eSignet authentication layer allows identity verification flows that can be embedded into openIMIS enrolment or claims workflows.

  • It supports linkage with MPI systems, enabling interoperability in DCI-aligned ecosystems.

Security & Governance

  • MOSIP is designed for national-scale identity systems, offering advanced biometric deduplication, audit logs, data encryption, and role-based access controls.

  • eSignet supports user consent management, tokenized access, and data minimization, enabling GDPR-like compliance.

  • Strong governance model supports integration with civil registration, financial systems, and social protection in a DCI-compliant framework.

Scalability & Interoperability

  • Deployed in multiple countries (e.g., Philippines, Morocco, Ethiopia), MOSIP is optimized for national population scale (100+ million records).

  • Interoperable via standard APIs and authentication protocols; its identity assurance services can be invoked by openIMIS via OAuth2 and integrated into FHIR-based workflows.

  • Supports both online and offline registration and works well in federated architectures.

image-20250630-084058.png

 

 

 

IDPASS

Integration & Standards

  • IDPASS provides open-source libraries and APIs for digital identity issuance, including QR code-based identity documents, biometric matching, and portable credential storage.

  • However, it does not natively support healthcare standards like FHIR, and integration with openIMIS would require custom adapters for patient matching or enrolment.

  • Best suited for intermittent connectivity or low-resource settings where MOSIP is too heavy.

Security & Governance

  • IDPASS uses encrypted credentials, biometric deduplication, and offline identity validation to support secure use cases in the field.

  • While it has fewer features than MOSIP for national governance or identity federation, it is strong in privacy-preserving design and community-level self-management of identity.

  • No integrated authentication broker like eSignet, but compatible with lightweight ID verification flows.

Scalability & Interoperability

  • Not designed for nation-scale ID ecosystems, but can support thousands to hundreds of thousands of identities in humanitarian or localized use cases.

  • Supports offline verification and portable identity via smartphones or field tablets.

  • Limited out-of-the-box interoperability with openIMIS, but could serve as a transitional or fallback identity layer in fragile or remote environments.

ID-PASS-Logo-Artwork-Orange-Black.svg

 

 

 

Summary Table

Feature Category

MOSIP

IDPASS

Feature Category

MOSIP

IDPASS

Integration & Standards

✅ OAuth2, OIDC, REST; API-first; eSignet

🟡 Basic APIs; no native FHIR; limited standards

Security & Governance

✅ National ID-grade; encryption; audit logs

🟢 Lightweight encryption and biometric matching

Scalability

✅ 100M+ scale, proven in deployments

🟡 Limited to community-scale (10K–100K identities)

Healthcare Interop

🟢 Interoperable via openIMIS with mapping

🔴 Requires heavy customization for openIMIS

Best Fit

National ID, openIMIS enrolment & fraud prevention

Local ID, field-based verification, digital vouchers

Did you encounter a problem or do you have a suggestion?

Please contact our Service Desk


This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/